Friday, October 7, 2011
Public Alienation
In the world of social media, the rules change. What was relevant yesterday, is long since forgotten today. People who are just sitting at home writing, are revered, followed, and loved by many. A person can be on top of the blogging world, and barely be known outside of it.
But the blogging world? We are big. We are huge, in fact. Blogging popularity has nothing to do with how pretty you are, or what your job outside is. It has everything to do with relating to the public at hand, and posting something that someone, somewhere enjoys.
You might be seen by 12 people. Or, you could have a Dark Army of over 165,000 twitter followers that read your blog religiously. The beauty of blogging, is that we get what we want said out- and normal, every day people just like us listen.
This is why Public Relations companies have been pitching their products to us for years. Want someone to order a dress from a company? Yes, you could spend millions on advertising in main stream media. Or, you could give one or two away to bloggers, and ask that they, in turn, do the same.
We trust what bloggers have to say, because they are normal, every day people. So when one of them is attacked by a suicidal PR firm, we fight back- and number into the thousands. By the time this shit storm of PRFail is done being talked about, it will be millions.
Yesterday, the PR firm BrandLink Communications sent out a basic form email pitch. Something tons of PR firms do, and something a lot of bloggers hate. Not all, but a lot. This particular pitch wound up in the hands of Jenny at Thebloggess.com.
Without going into the full nightmare, I'll just say this. Jose is Vice President at BrandLink Communications, and after seeing Jenny's reply, he hit Reply All, and sent an email to his company calling her a Fucking Bitch.
Reply all goes to everyone, Jose. Even the person you didn't want to reply to. Yes, it went straight to Jenny.
Jenny wrote back a long reply, and explained who she is as a blogger. If you have never read her page? Do so. Immediately. Jose wrote back that she should be glad they even felt her relevant enough to pitch an idea to.
In terms of public relations? That was not relating to his public. That was alienating her. She in turn posted to twitter what happened.
Do you know how far a woman with 165,000 followers can go? Let me assure it- really far. Add to the fire actor Wil Wheaton, and author Neil Gaiman helping spread the word, each with nearly 2 million followers, and word gets around.
In the upcoming days, BrandLink Communications will learn how well they deal with a shit storm. And honestly? I wouldn't be shocked if they lost clients over this. They called a woman blogger a Fucking Bitch for not wanting to pitch a post about a Kardashian sister in panty hose.
Neither do I. And I doubt I would have been as nice as Jenny in ANY of my replies to the matter at hand.
And apologies are best served when they A) don't infer that the entire matter was started by the wronged party, and B) actually contain an apology.
Let this be a lesson to PR firms everywhere. Bloggers are relevant, and our reach may not look long, but it is. When we need them to, our words can spread to millions, and they last forever.
PR stands for Public Relations. Not Public Alienation.
UPDATE: I almost feel like I should feel special- @Brandlinkcomm replied to one of my tweets.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

Well I damn sure know I never want to piss you off!
ReplyDeleteWell said!
Cranky Old Man
ROFL - that was great. loved the lead-in image too. Looks like they're still getting hammered on Twitter to boot.
ReplyDeleteThanks Cranky :) It just irritates me that these PR firms think we're great to advertise for them for free, but that we're not relevant.
ReplyDeleteTreat us like dirt, and you'll see how relevant we are.
I can only respond by quoting the one and only Bloggess . . . "And that's why you don't fuck with the critchety!"
ReplyDeleteHahaha. Have you seen the whining tweets from BrandLink today? "I am sad that with all the lessons to be had this is now turning into a bullying platform, two wrongs don't make a right." As if cursing at and insulting a person they thought was defenseless isn't bullying. And as if everyone on twitter noticing *is*.
ReplyDeleteI know, right? They're whiny on their facebook page, as well. And also? Aside from mentioning The Bloggess, I'm the only twitter person they mentioned directly. Score. My page has blown up today. LOVE that. Bad PR leads to massive page hits for me.
ReplyDeleteI just can't get over their reaction. Sure, boneheaded move in the replay all thing in the first place. But this is a PR firm.
ReplyDeleteThink about that. They get paid to spin things.
They are mostly whining, complaining about the flu publicly and the one chick's sister (does she even work there?) is asking people to lay off.
Not to belittle the power of the stay at home mom and blogging, but again, these are professionals who deal with public relations, and they just got owned at their own jobs.
You have been issued a challange.
ReplyDeletesee my post:
http://www.joeh-crankyoldman.blogspot.com
cranly old man
Calling her a fucking bitch while Don Draper is busy doing all the fucking... epic fail Jose..
ReplyDeleteI held a giveaway that a company sponsored. Only when it was time for them to ship the product that they offered to giveaway. The company did not do it. I lost a bunch of readers over this and the company still has not given my reader the promised items. I have been embarrassed by the entire episode and I will be more careful with what I choose to do with further giveaways.
ReplyDeleteI lost half of my readers. They all went together the left thinking I cheated the lady.